Ohio school districts refuse to compete with nuns

State Rep. Matt Huffman is trying to build support for a promising effort
to expand private school vouchers to more working-class families in
Ohio. In order to appease recalcitrant school districts, whose
executives vocally oppose the measure, he may remove any benefit
youngsters in wealthier districts could hope to get out of the program,
however.

Originally, the bill would have granted vouchers of up to $4,626
based on a family’s economic circumstances. But managers in more than
300 school districts have complained about the possible loss of state
and local funding, apparently afraid of competition for students’
dollars from the parochial school down the block. Huffman now wants to
limit the amount of each voucher to the total per-pupil aid the child’s
school district receives from the state. This means that children in
property-rich suburbs, where a growing number of poor families are concentrated,
could get just a few hundred bucks a year when they leave for a private
school, while many thousands of dollars stay with the school district.

It’s hard to imagine a worse trade-off: Districts get to keep the
cash without providing services, while poor and working-class parents in
the ‘burbs are forced to scrimp and save even more than their urban
counterparts to have some measure of control over their children’s
education. Choice-friendly legislators and advocacy groups in Ohio
should ask themselves, who are the state’s education dollars intended to
benefit: school budget officers, or kids?

More By Author

Related Articles