Posted on April 18, 2008 at 12:45 pm by Liam Julian

Mein textbook?

The Discovery Institute’s David Klinghoffer defends the link—made by the new Ben Stein movie, Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed—between Nazis and Darwinism. I wish I could write on this with more authority, but the D.C. advanced screening of Expelled was canceled.

I just don’t get it, though. Klinghoffer’s piece points out how Hitler used evolution and Darwinism in his propaganda and his personal thought. But nowhere does Klinghoffer discuss why inclusion of such historical instances is at all appropriate in a film that purports to investigate how evolution is taught in modern-day American science classes.

I think it’s safe to say that Expelled is inaccurately juxtaposing Nazis with those who defend teaching evolution in public schools. The New York Times reviewer wrote that Expelled is “[o]ne of the sleaziest documentaries to arrive in a very long time,” and I’m inclined to believe her.

You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

Comments

  1. Karl Priest:

    For years, the claim has been made that evolution is an
    inverted-fantasy religion taught in the public schools in violation of
    the First Amendment of the Constitution of the United States of
    America.

    1. Evolution was invented by Anaximander 2,500 years ago as an extension of the Gaea, Mother Earth, religion.
    2. The entire universe, viable and nonviable alike, has always devolved, the exact opposite and excluder of evolved.
    3. Every event in this universe is a devolutional event because some of the converted energy is lost to future events.

    Biology eliminates evolution.

    See: http://www.josephmastropaolo.com/

Leave a Reply