Education Secretary Watch: Who will lead 400 Maryland Avenue?
I just got off the phone with a reporter wanting names of the primary contenders for the Secretary of Education spot if either Barack Obama or John McCain wins in November. Here are my thoughts:
John McCain
— Lisa Graham Keegan has to be considered the front-runner, if only because she’s McCain’s most trusted and visible education advisor (and has been for years). Plus she was a great state superintendent in Arizona, is telegenic, loves school choice and accountability, and is loved in return by the conservative/libertarian base. The only problem: her tenure at the Education Leaders Council ended in a mess, which might make Senate confirmation challenging.
— Tim Pawlenty is a real contender too. Passed over for the V.P. slot, he’s still got one of the highest profiles on education of any GOP governor, in part because he chairs the Education Commission of the States . He also pushed a major merit pay program in Minnesota and is good on choice and accountability. Surely he’ll get a job in a McCain Administration; the only question is whether this will be the one.
— I still think Mike Huckabee could be on the list. (Read more here .) He also chaired ECS, made support for art and music education a major piece of his presidential campaign, and might want a high-profile post with which he could stay in the national spotlight. (Younger readers: when Bill Bennett was secretary of education, it actually was a high-profile post.)
— What if McCain goes for a Democrat for this slot? He’s already promised a bipartisan cabinet. Still, conservatives will scream if he appoints anyone cozy with the teachers unions or opposed to school vouchers. So how about Cory Booker , Newark’s mayor? He’s a young up-and-comer who is happy to bash the unions and promotes all manner of school choice. And, yes, he’s a Democrat to boot. (He supports Obama for president but if McCain ends up winning...well, who knows?)
Barack Obama
— Janet Napolitano , Arizona’s governor, is someone I’m hearing more about lately. As the chair of the National Governors Association, she promoted "competitiveness," including through education. She chaired the Center for American Progress’s task force on education , and she’s generally considered a tough manager. I’m not sure she would excite either side of the Democratic schism (the unions or the reformers) but she would make for a safe pick.
— If Obama wants to side with the reformers, Jon Schnur might be the selection. He’s been one of Obama’s most visible surrogates on the education issue, runs New Leaders for New Schools, and served in the Clinton Department of Education. He might be considered too young, though, or too chilly towards the unions.
— Linda Darling Hammond is the right choice if Obama wants to solidify his base. But I strongly doubt he’ll go this way for his top pick, as it would indicate that he’s a conventional Democrat, after all. No one in the U.S. has done more to try to kill the Teach For America program—the bastion of the liberal education reform crowd.
— Former North Carolina Governor Jim Hunt is a better pick if Obama wants to appeal to both the unions and reformers. He’s a masterful politician, a Southerner, and widely respected on both sides of the aisle. He’s also passionate about national standards and tests and could conceivably be the one person capable of making that idea a reality.
Am I missing anyone? Let me know.
You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.





September 12th, 2008 at 8:15 pm
As an Arizonan, I can assure you that Governor Napolitano is indeed a tireless worker and a tough manager. She’s demonstrated some independence from the unions, and she is a very shrewd operator.
She is however the governor of a state where 44% of the 4th graders score below basic on the reading NAEP, with precious little improvement during her tenure. I wonder if anyone in the Senate would care about that.
September 12th, 2008 at 9:08 pm
I agree with most of your picks and their caveats, particularly with regard to Keegan and Schnur. There are a few other names I would toss out. On the GOP side, former Mass. Gov. Jane Swift has certainly been put out in front on the issue, and could work if Keegan appears problematic. If NCLB reauthorization is a priority, Buck McKeon would be strong. But you also need a supe on the list, and Paul Vallas is probably the best option (unless he is going back home to run for gov of Illinois again)
On the Dem side, I’d go with Gov. Easley over Hunt. Joel Klein could be a strong supe candidate, but Arne Duncan is more likely (despite Russo’s objections). Ed Rendell would be a nice darkhorse, though.
September 13th, 2008 at 12:43 am
I saw an article, recently, comparing hispanic/minority scores in Florida and Arizona. Jeb Bush certainly helped turn Florida schools in the right direction. The “people” who ran Florida education under Jeb could provide great insight. I agree with Ladner’s comment - Arizona seems to be having real problems, academically.
November 8th, 2008 at 2:17 am
As a person in Florida, I suggest Jeb in the position of Ed Secretary may be akin to giving gas and matches to a pyromaniac. Look behind the spin and missing information, such as a retention policy purging poor scorers from grade 4 and the initiation date of the retention policy, and you see new information.
Research on your own rtaher than unequivocally accepting what is presented by persons with political motives. Jones refers to Ladner’s article in the above post. At this time, the election is over. Jeb’s spinners can rest and look for someone who truly does great things for students to support rather than dceive through smoke and mirrors.